Skip to content
Claim Wars · Season 1 · Episode 19

The Guess

An uncertain speed estimate becomes a definite number in Tom’s report. TSL restores the missing word: guess.

Explore the real law behind this episode

Transcript

TSLHe guessed the speed of his car. Tom dropped the word guess.

Tom BriggsYou said forty. That goes in the report.

TSLYou asked for a guess. Now it is a fact?

TSLWhen describing a crash, separate what you know from what you estimate. Say when you are unsure, and correct inaccurate summaries in writing.

Behind the episode

The Guess: Keeping Estimates Separate from Observations

An uncertain estimate becomes a definite speed in Tom's report. The problem is the missing qualification. Accurate claim information should distinguish a remembered observation, an estimate, and something the speaker does not know.

Explain the basis for the number

Looking at a speedometer is different from estimating speed from traffic flow afterward. Describe which occurred and when. If you do not remember a detail, say so rather than selecting a number because a question demands one. Do not replace an honest uncertainty with a confident statement that seems more helpful. Preserve any original recording, written statement, or questionnaire you were given.

Make a factual, dated correction

Identify the exact sentence that is inaccurate, what you originally meant, and the basis for any correction. Request a copy of the relevant summary and ask that the clarification be included in the file. Keep both versions and the date sent. A correction adds context; it does not erase the earlier statement or require everyone reviewing the claim to accept the new account.

Speed is evaluated in context

A.R.S. 28-701 requires reasonable and prudent speed in light of conditions and hazards. A single reported number does not, by itself, establish every aspect of collision fault. Timing, roadway conditions, and other evidence may matter. Under A.R.S. 12-2505, causally contributing claimant fault generally reduces recoverable damages proportionally. Correcting an estimate is not a promise that no fault will be attributed to the speaker.

Questions this episode raises

Should I give an exact speed if I cannot remember it?
Do not invent precision. Explain what you actually remember and whether a figure is an estimate, including the basis and limits of that estimate.
Will a written correction remove the earlier statement?
Not necessarily. Preserve the original and the clarification. Both may be considered when evaluating what happened and how reliable the account is.

Sources and further reading

Episode explanation by Impact Legal. Updated .

Call Now Button