Truck vs Motorcycle - The Fix
TSL follows the truck-versus-motorcycle story into the records behind the claim.
Explore the real law behind this episodeTranscript
TSLA truck hit a motorcyclist and both carriers are lowballing. Here is how you beat the bias.
TSLThe fix is to build the case for it. Get the truck's ELD data — the electronic log. Get the dashcam. Get the maintenance records. Get the driver's qualification file.
TSLBecause when the truck is clearly at fault under Federal Motor Carrier Safety Administration rules, bias doesn't matter. And if the rider survived — the case is worth more, not less. Future medical.
TSLLoss of function. Ongoing care. Every year of shortened life expectancy counts as damages. Don't take a lowball on a life-changing case.
Truck vs Motorcycle: Evidence and Future Losses
TSL shifts the discussion from assumptions about a rider to records about the truck. That is a useful direction for an investigation. The records must still establish what happened, and the injury claim must be evaluated from the rider’s actual losses.
Preserve the records that answer the disputed question
Electronic logs can help establish duty status; dashcam footage can show vehicle movement. Maintenance records and driver qualification files answer different questions about the equipment and driver. Identify the carrier, truck, trip and relevant dates so preservation requests are specific.
Federal duty-record retention rules generally require specified records for at least six months. Do not assume footage has the same retention period. Preserve original exports and timestamps, and compare the truck’s records with scene photos, witnesses and available motorcycle evidence.
A regulation does not decide every fault issue
Identify which rule applies and how any violation contributed to the collision. Evidence of a violation does not automatically eliminate disputed causation or rider fault. Arizona’s comparative-negligence statute generally reduces damages for causally relevant claimant fault, subject to its stated exception. A stereotype about motorcyclists is no substitute for evidence of a particular act.
Survival is not an automatic value multiplier
The episode’s statement that a surviving rider’s case is necessarily worth more is too broad. Arizona’s damages instructions focus on losses established by evidence, including injury effects, necessary care, earning capacity and loss of enjoyment. Future care and effects require supporting evidence.
Life expectancy may inform the duration of proven losses; it is not a stand-alone price for each shortened year. Medical prognosis, care needs and work limitations require qualified assessment. Neither survival nor a regulation violation guarantees a settlement amount.
Questions this episode raises
- Does an FMCSA violation automatically establish the entire claim?
- No. Applicability, causation, damages and any comparative-fault issues still need analysis.
- Is a surviving rider’s claim always worth more?
- No. The available damages depend on the individual evidence and applicable claims, not that comparison.
Sources and further reading
- 49 CFR 396.3: vehicle inspection and maintenance records
- 49 CFR 391.51: driver qualification records
- 49 CFR 395.8: duty records and retention
- A.R.S. 12-2505: comparative negligence
- State Bar of Arizona: personal injury damages instructions (2025 revision)
Episode explanation by Impact Legal. Updated .